Key Takeaways:
- Your in-house prospect database consistently outperforms rented or purchased lists.
- Recency matters—but relationship matters more.
- Most marketers underinvest in their database while overspending on new lead acquisition.
- Database prospects respond at multiples—not percentages—above cold lists.
- Testing proves: the closer the relationship, the higher the response.
- In 2026, database-first marketing is essential for ROI, AEO, and AI-driven discovery.
Marketers love new leads.
They chase them.
They budget for them.
They obsess over them.
And in the process, they often neglect their most valuable asset:
Their own database.
People who:
• Have already raised their hand
• Have already responded
• Have already engaged
• Have already shown interest
These prospects are not “old leads.”
They are your best prospects.
The Question Most Marketers Get Wrong:
What about the people on your in-house prospect list?
People who:
• Responded to a mailing
• Requested information
• Clicked, opted in, or engaged
• But didn’t convert yet
If they didn’t convert the first time, are they still better prospects than someone hearing about you for the first time?
And does the length of time they’ve been on your list matter?
The Test:
We reviewed a real-world list test originally conducted by G.A. Wright, comparing:
- A purchased compiled B2B list
- An in-house prospect list
The in-house list was further segmented by how long the prospect had been on the list.
The objective:
Determine whether time-in-database impacts response—and by how much.
The Results (Still Eye-Opening)
The purchased compiled list pulled a response rate of 0.306%.
The in-house prospect list didn’t just beat it.
It destroyed it.
Here’s how:
- Current-year prospects:
1230% better — 4.070% response rate - 1 year back:
816% better — 2.082% response rate - 2 years back:
357% better — 1.398% response rate - 3 years back:
315% better — 1.269% response rate - 4 years back:
173% better — 0.835% response rate
Even prospects who had been inactive for four years still outperformed cold lists—by a wide margin.
Why This Matters More in 2026 Than Ever
Today’s marketers face:
• Rising digital costs
• Lower organic reach
• Algorithm dependency
• ROAS pressure
• AI-driven discovery replacing traditional search
Yet many still pour the majority of their budget into new lead acquisition, while underfunding:
• Database reactivation
• Prospect nurturing
• Retargeting
• Sequential messaging
• Multi-touch follow-up
That’s backwards.
Your database:
• Is cheaper to market to
• Converts at higher rates
• Improves lifetime value
• Feeds AI and AEO signals
• Strengthens retargeting and personalization
Neglecting it is one of the most expensive mistakes marketers make.
The Real Insight from This Test:
Recency helps—but relationship wins.
The closer the relationship:
• The higher the trust
• The higher the response
• The lower the cost per acquisition
A prospect who once raised their hand—even years ago—is fundamentally different from a cold name.
They know you.
They’ve noticed you.
They’ve engaged.
That matters.
Action:
If your marketing strategy is heavily weighted toward new leads while your database sits underutilized, it’s time to rebalance.
Michael and the CDMG team specialize in:
• Database reactivation
• Prospect segmentation
• Retargeting and follow-up strategies
• Integrated digital + direct response programs
• AEO-optimized content that works with AI, not against it
Email Michael at [email protected] or call him at 615-933-4647.
A short strategy call can uncover revenue you already own.
We can also take your list of prospects and match them against the master list of people who are currently active in your market, so you can even further discover the gold.
FAQs:
Q: Should we still pursue new leads?
Yes—but not at the expense of your existing database. The highest ROI usually comes from balance.
Q: How often should we market to our database?
More often than most marketers do. Frequency should be tested—not feared.
Q: What about “old” leads?
As the test shows, even multi-year prospects outperform cold lists.
Q: How does this apply to digital marketing?
Database insights drive retargeting, lookalikes, personalization, and AI visibility.
Q: Why does this matter for AEO and AI?
AI favors brands with engagement signals, repeat interactions, and clear authority—your database fuels all three.
About Craig Huey:
Craig Huey is President of Creative Direct Marketing Group (CDMGinc.com), a 30-year leader in direct response advertising and multi-channel marketing. Under his leadership, CDMG has:
- Tested more than 10,000 digital marketing variables.
- Mailed over 10 million pieces of direct mail in the last year alone.
- Won more than 120 awards for marketing excellence.
Craig is also the publisher of Direct Marketing Update, the trusted newsletter for company presidents and marketing directors looking to maximize ROI with cutting-edge, accountable advertising strategies.
Unlock Explosive Growth with CDMG, Inc.
Your Partner for Digital Success
In today’s fast-paced world, you need more than just an agency—you need a partner who drives growth, amplifies your brand, and delivers results that matter. That’s where CDMG comes in.
We’re not just another ad agency. We are a top advertising and marketing powerhouse specializing in driving real, measurable results and profits. Our award-winning team, led by marketing veterans Craig and Caleb Huey, is dedicated to supercharging your advertising efforts and transforming your business.
Why CDMG?
• Proven Success: 120 prestigious awards in 2024 alone.
• Data-Driven Strategy: We don’t guess. We know what works. Our campaigns are crafted with precision to deliver maximum ROI.
• Expertise Across the Board: From media buying to digital copywriting, testing, and direct-to-consumer strategies—we’ve got it all covered.
• Real Results: We’ve helped launch new products, reposition brands, and turn small businesses into multimillion-dollar success stories.
Let us help with your video needs!
We produce:
• Pre-roll videos
• Video sales letters (VSLs)
• TV commercials
• Infomercials
• Addressable TV
• Videologs
…and much more!
Whether you’re looking to launch a new product, reposition your brand, or supercharge your e-commerce growth, CDMG is the partner you need to dominate your market.
Are you ready to see how we can drive your growth?
Let’s talk. Call Michael Oppenheimer at 615-933-4647 or email [email protected] today.
Don’t wait—start transforming your marketing results now with CDMG, Inc.
Act now, grow faster, and achieve more with CDMG.